In the 1970s, when Medicare was first introduced in Australia, dental care was notably excluded. Decades later, this oversight continues to impact Australians, leaving many grappling with the financial burdens of dental treatment.
Current statistics reveal that Australians shoulder a greater share of dental costs compared to other health services. This situation has led to a higher percentage of individuals delaying or forgoing dental care due to financial constraints—more so than their counterparts in many affluent nations. As dental health declines, treatment costs continue to rise, prompting numerous reports and inquiries advocating for universal dental coverage.
The recent support from the Greens, alongside backing from Labor backbenchers, raises the question: Is it finally time to integrate dental care into Medicare?
Opponents, such as the Australian Dental Association, argue that expanding Medicare to include dental services is overly ambitious and costly, highlighting the need for a larger dental workforce. They suggest a more cautious approach, initially focusing on vulnerable populations, particularly seniors.
While starting small may be pragmatic, limiting the scope of reform would be misguided. The financial burden of dental care affects not only the most disadvantaged; over two million Australians avoid seeking dental treatment due to costs. Moreover, over 40% of adults typically delay visiting a dental professional for over a year.
Incorporating dental services into Medicare would necessitate a significant increase in the dental workforce, but a phased implementation over a decade could make this feasible.
The primary obstacle to including dental care in Medicare is its substantial cost, which would amount to billions of dollars that the federal government currently lacks. Australia faces a structural budget challenge, with government spending outpacing revenue growth in a low-tax environment coupled with high expectations for services. Health care expenses, particularly for hospitals and medical benefits, rank among the fastest-growing budget items.
To achieve equitable health care for all Australians, strategic decisions regarding dental services are essential, alongside necessary revenue enhancements and expenditure reductions in other areas.
When considering a new dental care framework, it is crucial to learn from Medicare’s past. Payments to private providers under Medicare have failed to adequately address the needs of communities requiring the most support, particularly in rural and disadvantaged regions where access to general practitioners is severely limited.
Mental health services also reflect this disparity, with the most deprived areas facing more than double the psychological distress of wealthier communities, yet receiving only half the Medicare-funded services they require.
With around 80,000 hospital visits annually for preventable dental issues, the need for targeted public dental services in underserved areas is clear. Investment in these services must be prioritized to address the oral health crisis affecting many Australians.
Another challenge is that Medicare payments often do not correlate with actual care costs or the health impacts on patients. To control expenses, funding for dental care should focus on essential treatments while excluding cosmetic procedures and orthodontics. Emphasizing efficient workforce models can also optimize care delivery, allowing dental assistants and therapists to provide a broader range of services.
Although the path forward presents challenges, there are viable options to curb spending and enhance revenue without impeding economic growth. Rethinking investments in major infrastructure and defense projects could yield significant savings, while revisiting funding arrangements like Western Australia’s GST deal could free up additional resources.
Tax reform—including adjustments to income tax breaks and superannuation concessions—could generate over $20 billion annually, creating fiscal space for improved services like universal dental coverage.
While tax increases and spending cuts are often unpopular, they may be necessary in the long run. The promise of enhanced dental coverage could be a compelling incentive for taxpayers to support these reforms.
Related topics:
